A Tale of Two MCATs: Which Should I Take?
January 24, 2013
With the major MCAT revision coming up in 2015, many students are starting to ask: which MCAT should I take? Is there an advantage to one test versus the other?
The short answer is: it’s possible to do either and score extremely well, but you’ll have to plan starting today.
What’s changing in the 2015 MCAT?
If you haven’t read our other articles about the MCAT 2015 exam, make sure to go back and check them out:
- The 2015 MCAT – Thoughts and Statistics
- The 2015 MCAT – What’s the Big Buzz?
- Keeping Up with the MCAT Test Changes
What classes will I have to complete before studying for the MCAT?
Both the current MCAT and 2015 MCAT will require one year (2-semester sequence) of physics, general chemistry, biology and organic chemistry (8 classes total). The 2015 MCAT will also require one semester of introductory psychology, sociology, and biochemistry (11 classes total). All prerequisites for the current MCAT could be completed in two years (taking biology simultaneously with general chemistry one year, and organic chemistry simultaneously with physics the second year). Thus, even if you’re currently a freshman, you could complete the requirements and take the current MCAT during the summer after your sophomore year (Summer/Fall 2014). However, if you are not positive that you’ll be able to complete these requirements in this time (that is, after all, a very rigorous courseload!), it behooves you to take behavioral sciences (psychology and sociology) during the first two years of undergrad as well.
The two word clouds above are created from AAMC’s own content lists for the current and 2015 MCAT. Click on the image to see a larger version!
Will there be any difference in applying with an “old” MCAT score or “new” one?
We do not anticipate this being an issue for the student. It is not 100% clear yet what schools are planning to do with current MCAT scores versus MCAT 2015 scores (this was a hot topic of debate in a few of the sessions at this year’s AAMC meeting), but schools were keenly aware that they’ll be looking at scores from both forms of the test — sometimes even from the same student!
According to their website, AAMC’s score-reporting service will release pre-2015 MCAT scores until 2017 or 2018. Further, “The AAMC is currently developing new materials, specific to the interests and needs of medical school admissions committees. These will provide detailed information about the scoring of the new exam, the confidence bands that are associated with them, and what test scores are and are not designed to tell them in a holistic admissions process” . In other words, AAMC and admissions committees are already figuring out the fairest way to score and interpret the new MCAT next to the current one.
What are the pros and cons of each?
In making your scheduling decisions, consider each of the following:
- Shorter in length (3 hours, 20 minutes required testing time + 45-minute trial section).
- Fewer pre-requisite classes (8 total). No psychology, sociology or biochemistry.
- Compared to 2015 MCAT, has a higher proportion of:
- Organic chemistry questions (about 20-25% of Biological Sciences section).
- Physics questions (50% of Physical Sciences section).
- General chemistry questions (50% of Physical Sciences section).
- Each question individually may have a large impact on score.
- Longer in length (6 hours, 15 minutes required testing time).
- More pre-requisite classes (11 total).
- Compared to current MCAT, has a lower proportion of:
- Organic chemistry questions (about 15% of Chemical and Physical Foundations of Biological Systems section).
- Physics questions (about 25% of Chemical and Physical Foundations of Biological Systems section).
- General chemistry questions (about 33% of Chemical and Physical Foundations of Biological Systems section).
- Each question individually has a smaller effect on score; more questions can be answered incorrectly without hurting score.
Can I just check out what each test will look like?
Absolutely! In addition to checking out AAMC’s website, come to a Kaplan Practice Test (available online, or at a school near you through the month of February) to see the style of the current exam, or check our 2015 MCAT-style Mini-Test online.
Regardless of the version you choose to take, start planning out your academic schedule now. You don’t want any surprises down the line! And rest assured, regardless of version you choose, Kaplan is here to help you get the top score you’re looking for. How are you choosing which test to take?
I graduated from Boston University with a BA in Musicology and am currently a fourth year in medical school at the University of Pennsylvania. I took Kaplan to prep for my MCAT. After such a great experience with my course, I couldn’t resist the opportunity to teach and tutor hundreds of pre-health students for the MCAT, DAT, OAT and PCAT in both our Boston – Haymarket and Philadelphia Kaplan Centers. I am one of the Content Managers for Kaplan's new MCAT 2015 course. When I’m not preparing for residency or teaching MCAT, I enjoy playing classical piano, exploring new cuisines and traveling on road trips.